From a quick googling, one site listed the ingredient under their polyester glitter category as PET glitter (same as what I wrote about), but I saw a lot of association with it as an alternative craft glitter so Id definitely try to dig in more to see what that means. In addition to refreshing your tired-looking eyes, No Filter ColourPop Concealer masks large pores, age spots, camouflage dark circles, and other blemishes visible on your skin with just one swipe. Aww thats nice! Its incredible how very small particles can cause searing pain on the eye so magnified! for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't When doing this ColourPop review, we checked customers experiences with the brand and the products they offer. Hi Christine In part of its findings, CIR wrote that a lack of case reports and no ongoing FDA regulatory actions suggested to the Panel that ocular injury is not likely. If, in fact, consumers sustain ocular injury from the use of PET glitter, then it seems it will fall to consumers to report those injuries to the FDA. , lilac dreams come true with our newest 9 pan palette , Create dreamy looks with this purple trio , Good vibes only with this 9-pan palette , Brighten up with this vivid violet with hot pink + purple pin points , A warm rust with a blue-green duo chrome finish in our famous formula . Im waiting the answer for my request, the package got lost, and I dont know if you send it again, because I have not received the mail back. My understanding is it is (or was) a better method to avoid issues with things like night driving, especially as they are able to work on a larger surface with this method; ergo more tissue is available for treatment. This was honestly a very interesting read! I actually tried to confirm with Lit that their glitters were eye safe, and they referred me back to my own warning notice posted on their glitters, so in a very roundabout way, they actually wouldnt confirm they were safe. Its renewed my love of makeup and reawakened my interest in playing with different looks and color. The blue liquid liner tends to run. This bronzer features super velvety-soft powders that add an attractive, natural-tanned glow to your face, especially when your skin appears dull. Medium, Olive, neutral undertones. Register. Wow Christine! ColourPop offers freebie goodies and promotions throughout the year. Per Allure, if there's another way of doing something, TikTok will find it, like with the latest TikTok beauty trend using lip liner as a tool for creating the perfect eye look. Oh, yes, PET glitter is used in a lot of cosmetics. But hey, as it can happen to anyone, this stuff just shouldnt be manufactured. If you need help purchasing a product directly from Allure, go to our FAQ. And Ive seen them wind up on my waterline or tear duct from exactly that! I love the bronzer and very much enjoy the Posh lipstick and lip liner. The Brella SweatControl Patch could be a game-changer for anyone with hyperhidrosis. Of all the things we are exposed to over the course of our lives Im sure a few specks of glitter are the least of my worries, but I do sometimes think about it, especially with the glitters that are specifically designed to break down. Glitters are not eye safe and it drives me nuts when I see companies (like ColourPop) put glitters in eyeshadow palettes especially ones that are aimed at more juvenile customers. So I spoke with two cosmetic chemists to get the factscan you use lip liner as eyeliner and vice versa? The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast. I wanted to ask what is the difference between glitter vs shimmer vs foiled vs metallic shadows? Lip Balm. Ill need to weed out shadows with glitter or microglitter fallout and just keep the ones that are formulated to stay on well. Im sorry, Im not familiar with that ingredient! ? The question is below, and the comment section of the blog has feedback, as well as the podcast. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and theyll be displayed as long as an account is active. product review requests, off-topic questions, or need technical support, please I plan on buying many more things from Colourpop. Hyaluronic ColourPop Tinted Moisturizer is available in a 43-ml tube at an affordable price, and it works perfectly over any moisturizer, sunscreen, and primer. MAC would also be a safe bet solely because of the overall solid quality and variety of products. Though these eyeliners cost just $7 a tube, ColourPop's creamy consistency rivals even the most high-end eyeliners. When I went to take the last one out, it rolled up into my eyelid and I freaked out trying to figure out how I was going to get it out..it took me an hour and it was rolled up in my eye but thankfully it came out without issues after I calmed down. Makeup palettes are gorgeous as expected, very pigmented and pretty good quality!! While I dont feel any personal need to be using large glitter on my eyes, Im thankful for your research into this. So a humidifier on my desk and constant eye drops and my eyes were finally moist enough to do the surgery again. The 100%-vegan-and-cruelty-free formula consists of marine ingredients that hydrate and protect your delicate under eyes. Please keep discussion on-topic, and if you have general feedback, a product review request, an There doesnt seem to be a way for consumers to determine if product A with a warning of not intended for use around the immediate eye area is actually any riskier than product B that calls itself an eyeshadow with no warning. Your California Privacy Rights. And the UK just banned over a thousand ingredients while the U.S. banned about 30. Rare Beauty Warm Wishes Effortless Bronzer Stick Swatches, Sephora Collection Colorful Blushes Swatches (2023), elf Halo Glow Contour, Highlight, Blush Beauty Wand Swatches, A Pink & Plum Eye Look ft. Sydney Grace x Temptalia, A Tropical Eye Look ft. Sydney Grace x Temptalia, ColourPop x Harry Potter Collection Yer a Disappointment, ColourPop. Your clarification would be appreciated and thank you again. A few customers did not like that ColourPop does not offer refunds and returns. Lightest, Yellow, slight yellow undertones. They also don't sell their products where animal testing is required by law. And makeup *should* be care-free and fun. The U.S. more or less expects cosmetic companies to self regulate. You mentioned some regulations and Im sure you didnt find much. Private Party ColourPop Bronzer helps you get a golden, sun-kissed glow at any time of the year. We recommend signing up to take advantage of personalized features like tracking products you own, viewing dupes that you already have, and more! Find swatches by color, product, formula, etc. Its not both. Eyebrows. Colourpop You're The Bestie Lippie Pencil Vault Set $38.99 New ColourPop 10 Pieces Lippie Stix Vault Bestie in show $39.99 New All Auction Buy It Now Best Match 120 Results Brand: ColourPop Formulation Buying Format All Filters SPONSORED ColourPop Lippie Pencil Liners Matte Vegan Vault Cruelty-Free Warms Cools NWOB $8.79 to $13.79 SPONSORED My goal was to do more research and present that information to readers and consumers so that they can make the best decision for themselves with more information as more brands add plastic glitter to their products (with or without warnings). I thought it was important to share because it can and does happen, so its not a would never happen to me! kind of thing either because sometimes I see people using well, Ive done it forever and never a problem as justification for why someone else should feel comfortable about it. You experience is going to make me more careful about make up removal too. I dont think thats a standard way of writing the ingredient, though. Then soak my lashes with an additional cotton pad to get rid of the mascara. I guess Ive been living under a rock because Im 43 and just discovered them. Now its fairly ubiquitous. Eye Makeup Remover. Contacted customer service and they would not send it to me even though it was in stock and available and after repeating myself countless times asking why I was unable to get the pallet I gave up. Combination skin. I have paid much more for shadow palettes and am glad I happened to find this brand. Private Party ColourPop Bronzer contains talc, which absorbs oil and moisture to prevent caking. ColourPop ranks 214th among Cruelty-Free sites. I never had dry eyes to start but did have to rely upon drops for at least a couple years after surgery. , As an eye care professional, I would like to say thank you from my heart for this! Size: OS Colourpop. Thank you! Also, any color additives used in cosmetics must be approved by FDA. FDA on Makeup. Also, high amounts of ingredients like fats, alcohol and waxes in lip liner, aren't exactly safe to use on eyes, per StyleCheer. Great read and I appreciate the work you put into this article. "I would not interchange these two products, since the one made specifically for eyes was formulated with pigments suitable for eye area," says cosmetic chemist Joseph Cincotta. Jump to a particular section if you know what information you're looking for! But if you insist on trying this lip liner TikTok hack, be sure to sanitize it with a cleanser that has alcohol in it and, if it is a pencil, try using a sharpener to clear the pencil of any contaminants before using it on your eyes. Furthermore, this concealer contains plankton extract, a versatile skincare ingredient that protects your skin from blue light and UV radiation, helps prevent toxins and pollutants from penetrating your skin, and reduces oxidative stress. For my more experimental purposes, it wasn't a great fit. I also realize that a lot of things can cause damage to the eye, even if technically safe, whether thats makeup or you know dust or sand! I try to ignore the pressed glitters in my Colourpop palettes but it would be better if they werent in there at all. Value 56. Thanks for making sure your readers are informed about the products they purchase (or in some cases, ones we dont purchase.) Nails. participate respectfully. This is yet another example of why you are the best beauty blogger in the blogosphere! Even though theres not a clear answer, the information is very helpful. Honestly all of the products are just such wonderful quality and super pigmented in the best way. Of the seven products tested, the only one that was noted as having any adverse event reported contained 46.272% of PET glitter with no size indicated; the other six products ranged between 8 and 12% concentration with three that provided size used and three that did not provide a size. Babies. Keep up the amazing work Colorpop!!! That means no lipstick, blush, lip liner, or general color product should ever go near your eyes. Awesomely comprehensive research and thanks for your personal input. By signing up, you agree to our User Agreement and Privacy Policy & Cookie Statement. I've ordered from them many times with no problems. I dont know if it would make much difference to dry eyes (doubtfully), but worth looking into. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Thank you so much for the research you have done on this matter on behalf of all of us who use eyeshadows. Combination skin. The own thing that I wonder about is that if an eyeshadow palette is being sold with a color that states not to be used on the eye due to the glitter, what in the world do they expect you to use it for? Light Medium, Neutral undertones. It seems like cosmetics and those who use them (mainly women) are not a priority to the US FDA, which I cant help but find sexist in a way, where womens health is not as high priority as mens. Very Light, Pink undertones. Need help finding your perfect foundation shade? Both borosilicates and synthetic mica are pretty common from what Ive seen, so Id definitely pay attention to what shades have given you trouble, but Id pay particular attention to see if theres any correlation with type of formula or particle size like a lot of people love how sparkly some Pat McGrath shades are, but they definitely have more visible sparkle to them and theres a range of sizes for both types of ingredients. I also wanted to inquire on whether there will be any modifications to approved color additives, particularly for use on eyes, for such color additives as Red 28 Lake (Ci 45410), Red 7 Lake (Ci 15850), and Yellow 6 Lake (Ci 15985). I contacted the company and they said that the usage is up to consumer discretion and people are using these shadows on the eyes with no problems. Pencils, I believe, are safer since you can sanitize and shave the tips. They fought for vegan, cruelty beauty, drove Lime Crime out of Sephora, ripped a new one on numerous companies for not having deep foundation shades but its been real silent on safety and plastic in makeup. Turns out you should never, ever use a lip liner as an eyeliner. Just thinking out loud here as I think if I tried to avoid the fluorphlogopite, Id end up not having any shadows at all. This particular formula may work better for simple lines along your lashes. Ive bought the hypoallergenic nars palettes before and my eyes stars watering and burning. Ill just read what their website says, then well look at the ingredients, and then review the FDAs regulation on colorants for cosmetics. "These higher amounts are necessary so that the lip liner doesn't dry out your lips but can cause irritation and discomfort to the skin around your eyes.". I am no chemist, but find my science degree comes in handy with these glitter discussions;). For example, ColourPop includes the warning "not intended for use in the immediate eye area" with their Pressed Glitters, which have been included in various palettes alongside eyeshadows and Pressed Pigments (another product "not intended for use in the immediate eye area"). Not to worry -- we can still help! Light, Yellow, slight yellow undertones. The answer is pretty shocking. Colorpop shipped me my order timely and accurately, and the items that I ordered arrived in perfect condition. If you are asking yourself: What stores sell ColourPop Cosmetics products? Its interesting to see how widespread it is, and that even older shades from Urban Decay may contain it. Im not here to to tell you to wear glitter or to not wear glitter. Im sorry that glitter in the eye happened to you, but so relieved that it turned out ok. This post is so, so amazing, and the reason there need to be people like you reporting thoroughly, critically, and honestly. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to So, the answer is that PET glitter continues to be not approved, and based on my reading of their response, its actually not approved in cosmetics, generally. So I hopped on the Google machine to see what the Internet had to say andcrickets. The hours Ive spent with my eyes almost glazed over and two separate windows with 30-40 tabs open in each for the last three days trying to find clarity ? This list is useful in particular for anyone who is concerned about Pressed Pigments (not glitter) as you can look up the various pigments used in a particular shade to see if it is approved for eye usage or not. Created with Sketch. This is where I stood a week ago, and Im really in the same place nowI dont feel like I have that much more information. This is true for any and all reactions to cosmetics. There are some derivatives like polybutylene, but it likely will have terephthalate with it. Im a senior and although this product is marketed toward younger customers, it works very well for me. However, larger-sized Synthetic Mica and Borosilicate products are currently permitted. 5/$50 Brand New Colourpop OH SIS Lippie Pencil - Smoked Paprika Lip Liner. I think they wrote the 008 as the particle size. I wasnt able to find any pending petitions regarding glitter, and you can also view final rules regarding color additives (generally) here. Im always excited to find someone who is from Calgary, Alberta (or who has even heard of it). Glad I normally prefer satin or matte finishes anyway. Thank you for all your hard work. This post is focused on the first concern as I recently had to go to an eye doctor after-hours to have a plastic particle removed that had gotten stuck to my upper eyelid immediately after I removed my makeup (not during wear) that would not flush out at home. Ive really only looked at finished cosmetics vs. raw ingredients, and it seems to turn up as polyethylene terephthalate. off-topic question, or need technical support, please Light, Neutral undertones. Baby Lotion. With knowledge comes power! The more uniform edge, as opposed to natural mica, seems to be why brands feel comfortable using larger particle-sized synthetic mica than natural mica. Readers often ask me what are my absolute, all-time favorites, and now you can find my current and long-time favorites all in one place! Light Plus, Pink, slight pink undertones. One big concern is that younger persons eager to experiment with make-up, but less aware of any warnings that might (or might not be) on the packaging, will run into a tricky situation because of this. The bit about to be safe when consumers use them according to their labeling, or as they are customarily used. is very interesting. Colourpop (56) CoverGirl (39) Crunchi (1) Dermacol (24) Doll Face (6) Dragun Beauty . BrandRated is reader-supported. COLOURPOP EYESHADOW QUESTION I recently discovered a new online American cosmetic company, Colourpop I was shopping on their website and noticed several products that are sold with their eyeshadows and liners that have the disclaimer not for use around the eyes. It looks like Colourpop is using red lakes that are not FDA approved for use around the eyes. behind and appreciate your patience! Verification can help ensure real people write reviews about real companies. Lip Stain. Youre lucky to live there, enjoy! But yes, every time I go back in the winter, my poor already dry eyes are so dry. So affordable too. , Be different with this shimmering sheer icy blue! We pride ourselves on being 100% cruelty-free, wallet-friendly and keeping our community at the center of our world. You made my brain hurt reading this. 4,844 likes, 156 comments - Rose Siard (@roseandben) on Instagram: "I did a #bridalmakeup look today on my story!! Nevermind the very large ones that ColourPop insists on putting in their eyeshadow palettes! Once the enforcement discretion period is over, FDA will resume our enforcement of these non-permitted colors.. Light Medium, Yellow, slight yellow undertones. Looking for the best makeup and beauty products? With regards to biodegradable glitters (and PET etc for that matter) I hope the FDA will assess the safety of ingesting them in small quantities. Im glad youre OK. , Our most wearable palette for a super sultry, smoked out eye! However, in looking at your list above and running the ingredients through my database, I see that PET is in quite a few highlighters (I know, not used on eyes, but still, interesting as I wonder if these products can scratch the face) and in one eyebrow product, Fenty MVP pencil. Dry skin. Sort By. When jt arrived it was missing the actual Mandalorian pallet. Its cold as heck here right now! I have always gone for the expensive high end makeups but after Covid Ive been having to save where I can. Youre an absolute pearl. . #iframe://www.facebook.com/plugins/like.php?href=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook.com%2Fallure&width&layout=standard&action=like&show_faces=true&share=false&height=80|||. So, I didnt want people to take what happened to me and run with it in an alarmist way either so I tried to present ALL the information possible so that it can be more about readers armed with whatever info is available and making the decision based on their personal comfort level. Ginger King, a cosmetic chemist is completely against using lip products around your eyes, per Allure. However, we are exercising enforcement discretion for a period of time.. I feel like acknowledging PET glitter safety/legality as a gray area is a bit taboo, and its wonderful to read a thoughtful breakdown of the different kinds too! A lot of ophthalmology organizations didnt turn up any results when I tried searching their websites for glitter and/or cosmetics (generally) information or guidance. Reviewers complaining about ColourPop most frequently mention customer service, credit card, and phone number problems. FDA-regulated product. In the Cosmetic Products Manufacturer category. Light, Pink, moderately pink undertones. Thank you for sharing the current status quo with us! ColourPop Oh Snap Lippie Pencil. Made in the USA, we imagine, innovate, test, and manufacture all under one roof. Needless to say, Im not wearing them anymore, and might try to get another named brand company that isnt some off brand youtuber approved /money maker too type deal. We try to approve comments within 24 hours (and reply to them within 72 hours) but can sometimes get Apply tape (if its very sticky, remove a bit of the stickiness on the back of your hand) with light pressure on the glittery area and remove, and start again with fresh tape, and go on for as long as youve removed as much as you can. Our ColourPop tinted moisturizer review discovered that you need to prepare your skin with a hyaluronic hydrating primer if you want extra hydration. I was very happy with the smooth order experience, fast shipping, and careful packaging of items in glass bottles to prevent breakage. FWIW, she thinks very highly of the Beauty Brains scientists, and their blog and podcast. Thank you very much for your well researched piece, Christine. . That product is in a lot fewer shadows and Im pretty sure that the colors that have them are the ones that bother my eyes if theres any fallout. Login Thank you ? "Using unapproved colorants around your eye could even lead to blindness," says cosmetic chemist Randy Schueller, the editor of thebeautybrains.com. Its amazing how you can harness one negative experience and turn it into a systematic discussion about policy and regulation in the cosmetics Industry! I have never been dissatisfied and will forever support ColourPop cosmetics. Cruelty-free and budget-friendly cosmetics products that are good for your skin. This is excellent research, Christine! Love our content? This ColourPop concealer review also found that it was created with soft blurring pigments to allow for a crease-proof, matte finish, meaning that you do not need a filter. I reached out to the FDA via their online contact form on January 14th, 2020: I wanted to inquire whether glitter, Polyethylene Terephthalate, is an approved ingredient for eye cosmetics, such as eye liner, eye shadow, and so forth. I appreciate the insight. If you suspect that youve scratched your eye, even if youve been able to flush out the foreign body or bodies, seeing an eye doctor to determine the best course of action from there is a good idea. Also regarding Lasik. Almost all the products that ColourPop Cosmetics offers are vegan, meaning that they do not include animal-derived ingredients. Light Plus, Neutral undertones. Turns out you should never, ever use a lip liner as an eyeliner. Because this product contains Caprylyl Methicone, this alkyl methyl silicone gives it a silky feel. . Colourpop is cruelty-free Colourpop has confirmed that it is truly cruelty-free. Hyaluronic acid is one of the ingredients found in this product, and it is used as a humectant to help your skin hold on to water. I found PET glitter in newer releases like Marc Jacobs See-quins (not all shades but a fair amount), and even Pat McGraths Bronze Blaze (from the Bronze Seduction Palette) includes PET glitter. Also, dont use craft glitter in place of cosmetic-grade glitter! Looking for the perfect color? Im very happy with with all of my purchases so far. . While doing our ColourPop review, we checked some of the products they offer to see how safe they are, the ingredients they use to create them, and who should use them. Im thinking that learning about all this is a good way for me to clean out my collection some more. Eyelash Glue. Products like Stilas Glitter & Glow Liquid Eyeshadows contain plastic glitter in several shades and classic Urban Decay Eyeshadows (seems like most that were described as having micro-glitter) like Chopper, Gunmetal, and Midnight Cowboy (not an exhaustive list) also used PET glitter. So it's probably not a good idea to use lip liner on your eyes. Whatever goes on my face is going near my eyes, too, but I dont use anything specifically for my eyes . PET is a polyester resin (so a type of polyester) which is probably why it was referred to this way. The follow-up question is also what is the definition of safe because CIR says ocular injury is not likely but does, ultimately, say PET glitter is safe to use in eye cosmetics, so it seems safe is more of a spectrum of safety not that it is 100% safe. Available in 4-grams bottles, this concealer features citric acid to help even your skin tone, brighten, soften, and make your skin smooth by targeting dark spots and pigmentation. Food for thought as you make your own decisions. As per a certain company with many releases including more push on plastic glitter- do you think companies care your safety or your coin? , Make waves with this multichrome blue-violet-teal , Bring the heat with this multichrome bright copper-gold-green , Get the complete Chrome Liquid Eyeshadow collection! By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. The brand-new ColourPop Ultra Blotted Lip and new Blotted Lip shades will be available today at 10 a.m. PST on colourpop.com. COVERGIRL Exhibitionist Lip Liner, Lip Pencil, Creamy, In the Nude, 0.012 Fl Oz ,Lip Crayon, Lip Makeup, Intense Pigmentation, Self-Sharpening Pencil, Easy Application, Instant Definition 4.4 4.4 out of 5 stars (1,072) Its no fun at all. MAC Glitters used to have a similar warning, but presently, for many of their glitters, their warning is now Approved for adhesion on the eye area using Duo Adhesive.. . Briefly, with respect to the second concern: cosmetic grade glitter generally means plastic glitter or polyethylene terephthalate (PET). Synthetic fluorphlogopite is supposed to have a more uniform finish which does not contain any sharp edges (per Lush). The CIR study on polyethylene terephthalate linked in the post also looked at a few other forms, so that might be helpful, too.
